Holy Grails | November 24th, 2009
A young guy from the U.K. has been writing me this morning. He has been making a case for why Buffett is the best investor ever. I have said, “Sure up until his bailouts and sweetheart government daddies helped save him in the Fall of 2008. If not, he was toast.” The young guy responded:
As regards the bailout, to be frank, if there wasn’t a bailout last year, it wouldn’t have been just BRK that went down the tubes - it would have been the entire global economic system. The disintegration of the banking system = no more credit = extreme deflation. Dunn Capital Management and every other business wouldn’t have been able to get short-term credit to pay its employees and suppliers. Asset prices would have gone into the abyss. If you think that trend followers would have made money in such conditions, remember that (a.) the rule of law and the enforceability of legal claims on assets may well have broken down, leading to civil disorder (b.) markets may well have failed to function, (c.) there would be no access to assets held by prime brokers, because they’d have gone down with the banks (see LEH). Basically anyone without tinned food and a log cabin in Montana would have lost under such a situation. BRK with its oodles of cash and AAA credit rating would have been one of the last to fail. My point is that you have to disassociate the investor and his record from the company - if for some reason Dunn failed under such a scenario, it wouldn’t reflect on Dunn as an investor, because we are talking about an event that has nothing to do with his skill as an investor. So, yes, maybe Buffett did manipulate the system to his advantage, but would we all honestly rather he hadn’t? Personally, I think this argument is rather overdone - the Fed and Treasury knew what happened in 1929, and there is no way, Buffett or not, they were going to let all the banks fail. I believe it is possible to replicate Buffett’s strategy - or at least its core - as much as it is any trend follower - buy companies with high free cash flow, strong franchises, little debt, during market crises when the P/E comes down below 15 or 20.
Bollocks. 100% bollocks. This is how the college text books will be rewritten to continue to salute “value” investing. They tell us the system would have crashed, but all we know now for sure is that the likes of Buffett and GS were saved. That is not a worthy investment strategy to follow.
Related Links
Share Investor Blog - Stockmarket & Business commentary
Share Investor New Zealand Business News- Get more business news
Discuss this topic @ Share Investor Forum - Register free
Share Investor's Daily Forex Updates
Recommended Amazon Reading
![]() | The Real Warren Buffett: Managing Capital, Leading People by James O'Loughlin Buy new: $13.57 / Used from: $1.99 Usually ships in 24 hours |
![]() | Warren Buffett's Management Secrets: Proven Tools for Personal and Business Success by Mary Buffett Buy new: $16.50 |
Kindle 2/Kindle DX: Amazon's New Wireless Reading Devices (Latest Generation)







